[ENG Sub] My Girlfriend and My Ex Made Me Pick Who’s Hotter

Editorial Review

★3.8 / 5 — henhenta editorial rating (our own assessment, not the DLsite official user score)

This is a reverse-NTR harem fantasy positioned squarely in the guilty-pleasure territory that’s become increasingly central to Japanese adult voice work—the appeal here isn’t the fantasy of being desired, but the psychological friction of managing competing romantic claims. Shiroiruka’s “Eroi Naka” series mines the intersection of nostalgia, rural isolation, and relationship anxiety, which differentiates it from the straightforward seduction scenarios that dominate the mainstream catalog.

The work’s structural hook—a three-day narrative arc where an ex-girlfriend (cheerful, physically forward, anchored in past intimacy) and current girlfriend (urban professional, jealous-driven transformation, present insecurity) explicitly compete for validation through sexual escalation—creates a deliberately unstable emotional substrate. Rather than resolving tension, the premise deepens it: the bonus chapters advertise a “修羅場” (shura-ba) full confrontation where both parties drop pretense, followed by a paradoxical descent into collaborative seduction. This tonal whiplash from conflict to collusion is the work’s thematic gamble, and the warning about cardiac risk for sensitive listeners suggests the producers understand they’re trafficking in transgressive stimulation rather than comfort.

The foley-heavy production approach and emphasis on 90 minutes of immersive vocal performance indicate this targets listeners who prize acoustic authenticity and intimate proximity over elaborate fantasy framing. The combination of rural melancholy, guilt-inflected desire, and multi-perspective female vocalization is unusual enough to warrant attention from those fatigued by formulaic gentle-domination or healing-ASMR voices.

This is essential listening for anyone interested in how contemporary doujin voice work weaponizes emotional discomfort as erotic fuel, though the sheer intensity of its psychological manipulation makes it a difficult recommend for casual listeners.